Get Your Price Online. Start Free, No CC Needed.
IT contractors: PSB risk

Before you sign an agency contract as a corporation: the clauses that change your PSB risk

No clause makes a corporation safe from the PSB rules. See which clauses point to employee, which CRA may treat as neutral, and how one made-up contract reads on paper and in practice.

Last updated: · Published by Ashbridge Tax · How we write our guides

The short answer

No clause makes your corporation safe from the personal services business (PSB) rules. CRA reads your contract as evidence of intent, then checks the facts. A clause that gives the payer a right to direct you counts even if never used. CRA says confidentiality and intellectual property (IP) clauses may be neutral, when the nature of the work needs them.

All rules on this page are federal.

Who this page is for

This page is for Ontario IT contractors with a corporation. You are about to sign, or have signed, a contract with an agency or an end client.

It is not for these readers:

  1. Contractors on an agency payroll with a T4 slip. The PSB rules do not apply to them.
  2. Contractors still deciding whether to incorporate. See Should I incorporate as an IT contractor in Ontario?.
  3. Anyone who needs a clause written. Ask a lawyer. This page covers tax effects only.
  4. Contractors asking whether Ontario employment standards cover them.

Want tax planning priced? See Price, Start Free.

On this page

What a contract can and cannot do

Condition 5 of the PSB test asks one question. If your corporation did not exist, would you reasonably be an employee of the payer? CRA says this is a question of fact. See CRA's PSB factors.

CRA's employee test, RC4110, has two steps.

  1. Intent. CRA asks both sides what they intended: a contract of service (employee) or a contract for services (business). "Sometimes the intent can be found in a written agreement."
  2. Facts. CRA checks whether the facts match that intent. In CRA's words, "all of the facts, including the actual terms and conditions of employment, determine a worker's employment status, not just the intention."

So "business-to-business" and "contract for services" are evidence of intent and nothing more.

But the contract also sets out rights. CRA says: "It is the right of the payer to exercise control that is relevant, not whether the payer actually exercises this right." So clauses matter, but a good clause cannot fix a bad working pattern.

Two limits:

  1. You cannot ask CRA for a Canada Pension Plan and Employment Insurance (CPP/EI) ruling on condition 5.
  2. CRA may read your contract. In a 2022 outreach project, CRA said it would ask businesses that hired PSBs for records, including contracts. See the 2022 CRA note.

Agency or end client? CRA's pages do not say which one condition 5 looks at (see the agency page).

Clause by clause: the CRA factor each one tests

Each row shows which way a clause points. Do not add up the rows: CRA "looks at the answers separately for each element and then together".

Clause CRA factor Points toward Check in practice
Label: "contract for services", your corporation Intent (step 1) Intent only Does the daily work match the label?
Direction: who assigns tasks and methods Control Employee, used or not Who assigns your tasks today?
Substitute: can you send one, who approves Hiring assistants Cannot hire: employee. Can hire and pay: business Has anyone used the right?
Tools: whose laptop and software Tools and equipment Payer's: employee, unless secure work needs it. Yours: business Do you own and pay for what you use?
Other work: permission, or full time and attention Control Permission or exclusive: employee. Free: business Can you take other work without asking?
Pay, risk and term: fee type, redo cost, project or open-ended Financial risk and profit See the text under the table Who pays to fix defects?

In the pay row, a flat fee, your own cost to redo poor work and a defined project point to business. So does a rate you negotiate at renewal. A continuous relationship points to employee.

Hourly pay leans employee, weakly. RC4110 says an employee "is usually paid on an hourly, daily, weekly, or similar basis". It adds that "some self-employed individuals are paid on an hourly basis".

Clauses CRA may treat as neutral

CRA's IT consultants page lists facts that "support the conclusion that a person is an employee just as much as they support the conclusion that the person is a self-employed worker". These may tell CRA little on their own:

  1. Confidentiality or assignment of IP clauses.
  2. Providing services for one payer at a time.
  3. Four items that CRA lists "for security reasons and because the nature of the work makes this necessary":
    1. work at the payer's place of business;
    2. a set work schedule, with timesheets that track project costs;
    3. the payer's secure equipment;
    4. no staff or subcontractors, because the payer does not allow them.

These are neutral only "when it is established that they are present because of the nature of the work and not because the payer controls how the worker does the work or has the right to this control." The reason decides.

Do not confuse item 2 with "no other services to any other party without written consent". That is a permission clause. CRA lists needing permission to work for other payers as an employee sign.

Worked example: one made-up contract, read on paper and in practice

Every fact below is made up. It decides no one's status and computes no tax.

A made-up data engineer is the sole shareholder of her corporation, which has no staff. A made-up agency, with no ownership link to her, pays it. Conditions 1 to 4 are met. The question is condition 5.

The contract (made up).

  1. Title: "Independent Contractor Services Agreement", between the agency and her corporation.
  2. Services: development work "as directed by the client's project lead".
  3. Hours: "not less than 40 hours a week" at the client's site, Monday to Friday.
  4. Substitution: "the Contractor may not replace the named individual without the agency's prior written consent".
  5. Equipment: the client supplies a secure laptop for locked-down work.
  6. Other work: "no other services to any other party during the term without written consent".
  7. Confidentiality, and assignment of IP to the client.
  8. Term: 6 months, can renew. The rate is negotiated at each renewal.
  9. Pay: $85 an hour on timesheets that the client approves.
  10. Termination: 2 weeks' notice by either side.

Step 1: on paper.

  1. Clause 1: evidence of intent only.
  2. Clause 2: a right to direct. Employee, used or not.
  3. Clauses 3 and 5: neutral if the locked-down work needs the site, schedule, timesheets and laptop. Clause 5 gives a reason (the secure laptop). Clause 3 does not.
  4. Clause 4: consent has no stated test, so the agency may refuse a substitute for any reason. RC4110 lists "The payer has no say in whom the worker hires" as a business sign. This clause gives the payer that say. It leans employee. A consent test tied to security vetting would sit closer to neutral (our reading).
  5. Clause 6: a permission clause. Employee.
  6. Clause 7: neutral, because work on the client's IP needs it.
  7. Clause 8: CRA lists a consultant who can negotiate the rate of pay at each contract renewal as a business sign. The renewable term could be a job or an ongoing role. Mixed.
  8. Clause 9: hourly pay. RC4110 says employees are usually paid by the hour, day or week, and some self-employed people are too. It leans employee, weakly. The clause is silent on who fixes poor work.
  9. Clause 10: CRA's IT page describes a self-employed contract as one that either side "may terminate with short notice". This leans slightly to business. That is our reading: CRA does not list it as a sign.

Step 2: the same contract, two sets of conduct (made up).

Conduct A.

  1. The client's manager assigns daily tasks and approves her absences.
  2. She works only for this client.
  3. The contract renews twice, automatically, in the same role at the same rate.
  4. Rework hours are billed as normal hours.

Conduct B.

  1. The client's written security policy requires all work on site, on its network, during team hours.
  2. A written statement of work lists deliverables, and she plans the work.
  3. She takes a second small client, with the agency's written consent.
  4. For two weeks, a colleague covers for her. Her corporation pays the colleague. The agency approves.
  5. At the first renewal she asks for $90 and gets it. She fixes defects at her own cost.

What moves.

  1. Clauses 2, 4 and 6 stay on the employee side under both. Under B the agency said yes each time. It still holds the right to say no.
  2. Clause 3 moves. Under B, the security policy explains the site and the hours, so they read neutral. Under A, no security reason is shown, and the manager also approves her absences. That is control. Clause 5 reads neutral under both: the secure laptop has its own reason.
  3. Clause 8's term and clause 9 move. The right to negotiate the rate is a business sign under both. The term moves. Under A, automatic renewals in the same role read as an ongoing relationship. Under B, she uses the right. For clause 9, she bears the cost of poor work under B, a business sign. Under A, rework is billed, so she carries no such risk.

Clauses 1, 5, 7 and 10 read the same under A and B. This is a reading of made-up facts, not a finding. Even under B, nothing here reads safe.

What changes the answer

  1. One project or an open-ended role. A business sign is being "hired for a specific job rather than an ongoing relationship". CRA's IT page accepts the same payer "for an extended period of time, as long as the consultant has several clearly defined mandates".
  2. Hourly pay or a fixed fee. RC4110 says an employee "is usually paid on an hourly, daily, weekly, or similar basis". A flat rate "generally indicates a business relationship, especially if the worker incurs expenses in doing the work".
  3. Who holds the right to say no. A consent right over substitutes or other work keeps the employee sign even if always granted. RC4110 lists "The payer has no say in whom the worker hires" as a business sign.
  4. Conditions 1 to 4. Under ITA s. 125(7), a corporation is outside the PSB definition if it employs in the business throughout the year more than five full-time employees, or if an associated corporation pays it. A one-person corporation paid by an unrelated agency meets neither.

Common mistakes

  1. Fearing confidentiality, IP and timesheet clauses. CRA says these may be neutral when the work needs them. An example is timesheets that track project costs on secure work. Timesheets used to monitor your hours appear in CRA's employee example.
  2. Reading financial risk into slow pay. "Paid only after the end client approves your timesheet" is a payment term. CRA's financial-risk signs are costs you carry, such as fixing late or poor work at your own cost.

Next steps

  1. Put each clause beside the table. Mark it employee, business, neutral or "depends on conduct".
  2. Read the statement of work and the end client's site rules, not only the agency contract.
  3. Write down how the work will run: who assigns tasks, where, with whose tools, who may substitute, who fixes defects.
  4. If a clause worries you, ask the agency to change it. A lawyer words the change.
  5. Keep the contract, every statement of work, timesheets, invoices and emails. If you already claimed the small business deduction on this income, read the CRA letter page.

The quote prices tax planning for your corporation. See Price, Start Free

Sources

  1. CRA, RC4110, Employee or self-employed. Dated 6 October 2023.
  2. CRA, Information technology consultants. Dated 28 July 2022.
  3. CRA, Factors that determine a PSB. Dated 2 June 2025.
  4. CRA, Question Period note on the PSB outreach. Dated 6 October 2022.
  5. Income Tax Act, s. 125(7). Current to 21 September 2026.
  1. Is your IT corporation a PSB? The five conditions.
  2. The agency told me to incorporate Why "the payer" is still an open question.
  3. A CRA letter about PSB status Contracts are what CRA asks for.
  4. Which expenses a PSB can deduct What PSB status costs in deductions.
Price First

You Can See the Price and the Work Before You Pay a Dollar.

Exact price. No preliminary call. No surprise invoice.

See Price, Start Free
See Price, Start Free