Get Your Price Online. Start Free, No CC Needed.
IT contractors: PSB risk

A CRA PSB audit letter: what to send and what your options are

Work out which kind of CRA letter you hold. See why a CPT1 ruling cannot decide PSB status, how the Voluntary Disclosures Program rules changed in 2025, and a made-up timeline in dates and dollars.

Last updated: · Published by Ashbridge Tax · How we write our guides

The short answer

A CRA letter about a personal services business (PSB) carries its own reply date. Meet it. A Canada Pension Plan and Employment Insurance (CPP/EI) ruling, form CPT1, cannot decide PSB status. The Voluntary Disclosures Program (VDP) is closed for an item once CRA starts an audit or investigation of it. If CRA reassesses, you have 90 days to object.

Gather contracts, invoices and proof of who directs your work. Decide your route before you send them. These rules are federal.

Who this page is for

This page is for Ontario IT contractors with a corporation who got a CRA letter that mentions PSB status or the small business deduction. It also fits contractors whose payer got one. The payer is the business that pays your corporation, often an agency.

It is not for these readers:

  1. Sole proprietors with no corporation. There is no PSB question for you.
  2. Readers with a letter about GST/HST or a personal return.
  3. Readers asking "am I a PSB?" See Is your IT corporation a PSB?.

Want to see the price of help with a CRA letter? See Price, Start Free

On this page

How long do I have to answer a CRA letter?

The date is in your letter. CRA sets the reply date in each letter. A formal requirement under the Act gives "such reasonable time as is stipulated in the notice" (Income Tax Act s. 231.2). If you cannot meet the date, ask the officer named in the letter before it passes.

If CRA audits and plans to change your return, it sends a proposal letter. You then have 30 days to agree or disagree (RC4188).

We found no CRA form, page or note that names a "PSB audit letter" or a "PSB questionnaire". Letters differ, so read yours before you assume a type.

CRA has published how its PSB pilot worked. In Phase 2, officers would ask a series of questions about the relationship between a PSB and its payer (pilot page). Phase 2 ran from October 2023 to June 2024. CRA has not said whether the pilot still runs.

Pilot participants were offered the chance to change their corporation tax returns (T2) or correct future filings without risk of penalty or immediate reassessment. That offer was for participants only.

A CRA note from October 2022 said officials would ask businesses that hired PSBs for books, records and contracts. It said the incorporated contractors would not be contacted, but the hiring business might be (CRA Question Period note). So the first letter may go to the payer, not to you.

What the officer tests is the five PSB conditions in CRA's PSB factors. All five must be true. Condition 5 asks whether you would reasonably be an employee of the payer if the corporation did not exist. CRA says it is a question of fact. The facts are your contracts, invoices and how the work really runs.

How far back can CRA go? For a Canadian-controlled private corporation (CCPC), the normal period is 3 years from the original notice of assessment (CRA).

There is no end date if the corporation made a misrepresentation because of neglect, carelessness, wilful default or fraud.

CRA can then reassess only the amounts linked to it (Income Tax Act s. 152). A waiver (Form T2029) filed in the normal period lets CRA reassess the matters it names until you revoke it. Revoking it ends that right 6 months later.

Can a CPT1 ruling settle my PSB status?

No. You cannot ask CRA for a CPP/EI ruling on condition 5 of the PSB test. Condition 5 asks whether you would reasonably be an employee of the payer if the corporation did not exist. CRA does allow a ruling on whether you are an employee of your own corporation.

A CPT1 ruling answers a different question: is a job pensionable or insurable for CPP and EI? A worker or a payer may ask. The request is due by 29 June of the year after the year the question relates to. The ruling covers specific periods. Unless it is appealed, it is final. See CRA's RC4110.

So a CPT1 ruling can matter for CPP and EI. It does not decide whether your corporation carried on a PSB. Do not wait for one before you answer a letter.

Which route fits your letter

The VDP gives relief from interest and penalties, never from the tax. CRA replaced the VDP rules for applications received on or after 1 October 2025. Older web pages may describe the earlier rules. Check the date on any page that quotes percentages.

Your situation (generally) Route Interest relief Penalty relief
No CRA contact, or only an education letter VDP, unprompted 75% 100%
A letter that names an error, or sets a deadline to correct one VDP, prompted 25% up to 100%
An audit or investigation started on that item No VDP no VDP relief no VDP relief
Your records show you are not a PSB Answer the letter with the evidence; no VDP needed not applicable not applicable
A notice of reassessment Object within 90 days of the notice date not applicable not applicable

Source: CRA, IC00-1R7 Voluntary Disclosures Program, dated 10 September 2025. For the objection row: CRA, Resolving disputes, dated 11 September 2026.

CRA decides each VDP application on its merits. It is not required to grant relief.

To fix a recent year that is not yet one year past due, CRA says you can request a reassessment of the T2. CRA explains this on its correct-filing page.

The circular classifies an application, not a letter. It treats an application as prompted when CRA has already identified an issue. Examples are a specific error, a deadline to correct one, or third-party information about you. It treats no contact, or an education letter with general guidance, as unprompted.

The table does not tell you which row your letter is in. A request for contracts and invoices is not named on either list. Neither CRA page says whether a review letter counts as an audit. Your adviser must read the letter.

If the VDP application is eligible, CRA grants protection from prosecution, and gross negligence penalties do not apply on the information disclosed. Eligibility needs all five conditions. One is payment of the estimated tax or a request for a payment arrangement. Read CRA's eligibility page before you decide.

Worked example: one made-up corporation, one made-up letter

Every fact below is made up. The example does not say that any corporation is a PSB. It does not say which route a real letter falls in.

Inputs (made up). A one-person IT corporation, a CCPC with a 31 December year-end. It has one agency client. It claimed the small business deduction on its 2024 return. If it is a PSB for 2024, it owes $40,000 more tax.

Interest to date is $4,000. Assume a $2,000 penalty would apply (made up).

Timeline (made up, with derived dates).

Date Event Basis
15 Aug 2025 Original notice of assessment, 2024 return made up
20 Oct 2026 CRA letter asks for contracts, invoices and details of who directs the work, 2024 and 2025 made up
20 Nov 2026 Reply date in the letter made up
12 Jan 2027 One possible outcome: CRA reassesses 2024 made up
12 Apr 2027 Last day to object to that reassessment 19 + 28 + 31 + 12 = 90 days after 12 Jan
15 Aug 2028 Normal reassessment period for 2024 ends 15 Aug 2025 plus 3 years

The reassessment on 12 Jan 2027 is one possible outcome. The other dates come from the letter and the law. If there were a misrepresentation because of neglect, carelessness or wilful default, the 2028 date would not apply.

The money, three routes. The $40,000 tax is owed in all three. Route A is not open once a letter names the issue. We show it to price the cost of waiting.

Line A: if it had applied before any letter B: prompted VDP C: audit already started
Tax owed $40,000 $40,000 $40,000
Interest left to pay $1,000 $3,000 $4,000
Penalty left to pay $0 $0 $2,000
Total $41,000 $43,000 $46,000

How each cell is built:

  1. Route A. Interest relief is 75% of $4,000, which is $3,000. Interest left: $1,000. Penalty relief is 100% of $2,000. Penalty left: $0.
  2. Route B. Interest relief is 25% of $4,000, which is $1,000. Interest left: $3,000. The circular says "up to" 100% for penalties. The table shows the ceiling. $43,000 is the lowest total this route can give, and CRA is not required to grant it.
  3. Route C. No VDP relief. $40,000 + $4,000 + $2,000 = $46,000.

The gap between A and B is $2,000. The gap between B and C is $3,000. Interest keeps running while you wait. The example ignores personal tax on any salary or dividends.

One more check. The 2024 return was due six months after 31 December 2024 (CRA). That is well over a year before the letter date. The 2025 return was due six months after 31 December 2025, which was less than a year before the letter date.

The VDP asks for information at least one year or one reporting period past due. Ask your adviser how that applies to 2025.

What changes the answer

  1. Whether an audit or investigation has started on that item. If yes, the VDP is closed for it.
  2. What the letter says. A letter that names an error or sets a deadline to correct one is generally prompted. An education letter is not.
  3. How old the return is. A newer year may need a reassessment request, not a VDP application.
  4. Whether you can pay. The VDP needs payment or an approved payment arrangement.
  5. What your records show. If the five conditions do not all hold, the corporation is not a PSB. Then the answer is evidence, not a disclosure.
  6. Who got the letter. The payer may have been asked for documents, not you. Tell your adviser if the agency has asked you for papers.

Common mistakes

  1. Missing the date in the letter. The date in the letter is the deadline. Ask for more time before the date, not after.
  2. Answering before you know the letter type. A reply that discloses an error may matter for the VDP. Ask an adviser before you send facts.
  3. Changing a contract to fix past years. Papers made after the fact may be treated as a misrepresentation. If so, the normal time limit does not apply. Ask a lawyer before you change anything.
  4. Missing the objection time. After a notice of reassessment you have 90 days from the date of the notice. A corporation that is not large need not pay the disputed amount while CRA reviews the objection. Interest can still run. See CRA's Resolving disputes.

Next steps

  1. Write down the letter's date, its reference number, the tax years it names, the reply date and the officer's contact. Add what it asks for.
  2. Put your records in date order. Include contracts, invoices and timesheets. Add proof of who owns the tools and emails that show who sets tasks and hours. Add records of other clients.
  3. Write a short factual note on each of the five conditions. Add the factors in RC4110: intent, control, tools, helpers, financial risk, investment and management, and chance of profit. Use only what the records show.
  4. Before you send facts, ask a CPA or a tax lawyer which row of the table fits. The choice to make a voluntary disclosure is yours and your adviser's.
  5. If a notice of reassessment arrives, mark the date. The objection time runs from the date of the notice.

The quote prices your corporate tax return (T2). See Price, Start Free

Sources

  1. CRA, IC00-1R7 Voluntary Disclosures Program. Page dated 10 September 2025. Applies to applications received on or after 1 October 2025.
  2. CRA, VDP eligibility. Page dated 1 October 2025.
  3. CRA, Factors that determine a PSB. Page dated 2 June 2025.
  4. CRA, Correct filing errors for a PSB. Page dated 20 November 2025.
  5. CRA, RC4110, Employee or self-employed. Page dated 6 October 2023.
  6. CRA, RC4188, What you should know about audits. Page dated 16 October 2023.
  7. CRA, When we reassess your T2 return. Page dated 11 September 2026.
  8. CRA, Resolving disputes. Page dated 11 September 2026.
  9. CRA, When to file your corporation income tax return. Page dated 26 May 2025.
  10. CRA, Personal services business pilot. Page dated 14 April 2026.
  11. Income Tax Act, section 152. Current to 21 September 2026.
  12. Income Tax Act, section 231.2. Current to 21 September 2026.
  13. CRA, Question Period note on personal services businesses. Note dated 6 October 2022.
  1. Is your IT corporation a PSB? The five conditions with IT examples, to see whether your corporation meets them.
  2. The agency told me to incorporate The CRA pilot figures and the agency route, if an agency asked you to incorporate.
  3. Should I incorporate as an IT contractor in Ontario? Three ways to take the same contract
Price First

You Can See the Price and the Work Before You Pay a Dollar.

Exact price. No preliminary call. No surprise invoice.

See Price, Start Free
See Price, Start Free