Get Your Price Online. Start Free, No CC Needed.
Doctors

RRSP or leave the money in your MPC? A side-by-side example

For interest, an RRSP keeps more than your MPC. For growth you never sell, the MPC can keep more. A mix lands near the RRSP. Every line shown, made up.

Last updated: · Published by Ashbridge Tax · How we write our guides

Quick answer

The answer depends on how the money earns: interest or growth. In the made-up example, each $100,000 of MPC profit leaves $75,700 after 10 years through an RRSP. Left in the MPC, it leaves $65,800 if it earns interest, or $84,800 as growth you do not sell.

A half-and-half mix lands about level with the RRSP. New RRSP room is capped at $35,390 for 2027, so most surplus can only stay in the MPC.

These results assume the top tax bracket when you take the money out. The tables also show two lower brackets.

Who this page is for

For: an Ontario physician with a Medicine Professional Corporation (MPC) and profit left after living costs. You wonder whether to pay it out for an RRSP or leave it in the MPC.

Not for:

Want an accountant to run this for your MPC? See Price, Start Free.

Contents

  1. How an RRSP, a TFSA and your MPC are taxed
  2. Key numbers side by side
  3. Worked example: Dr. Rao's $100,000
  4. What changes the answer
  5. Common mistakes
  6. Next steps

How an RRSP, a TFSA and your MPC are taxed

RRSP (federal). You deduct what you put in, so the tax on that money waits. You pay tax on everything you take out, at your rate that year (Income Tax Act, s. 146).

Your room for a year is the lesser of 18% of last year's earned income and the dollar limit, less any pension adjustment (CRA). If you belong to a hospital or university pension plan, the plan reports a pension adjustment, and it lowers your room. Unused room carries forward.

Dividends are not earned income, so they create no room (Income Tax Act, s. 146(1)). To build room through the MPC, you pay yourself salary. Salary paid this year creates room for next year. CPP and RRSP for incorporated doctors shows how much salary fills the room.

TFSA (federal). You get no deduction. Growth and withdrawals are tax-free (CRA). The limit is $7,000 for 2026. The CRA has not listed a 2027 limit.

Your MPC (federal and Ontario). Active business income up to the limit pays 11.2%: 9% federal (CRA) and 2.2% Ontario (Ontario).

Money the MPC then invests earns investment income. Federal tax on it is 38% less a 10% abatement (a reduction that leaves room for provincial tax), plus 10 2/3%. That makes 38 2/3% (Income Tax Act, s. 123.3).

Ontario's 2.2% rate covers active business income only. Investment income pays Ontario's general rate of 11.5% (Ontario). The total is 50.17%.

Part of that tax comes back. When the MPC pays a taxable dividend, it gets a refund of 38 1/3% of the dividend (Income Tax Act, s. 129). The refund cannot pass 30 2/3% of the investment income earned.

A capital gain is different (federal). Only one-half of it is taxable. The other half goes to the capital dividend account. The MPC can pay that half out tax-free if it files an election with the CRA (Income Tax Act, s. 83).

You pay personal tax on the dividends the MPC pays. They are non-eligible dividends. An MPC pays this kind from income taxed at the small business rate and from investment income (federal) (Income Tax Act, s. 89).

The dividend is grossed up by 15% (Income Tax Act, s. 82): you report more than you received. Then two credits reduce your tax:

Key numbers side by side

RRSP TFSA MPC
Room each year Lesser of 18% of last year's earned income and $35,390 (2027), less pension adjustment $7,000 (2026) No cap
Tax before it is invested None. The MPC deducts your salary and the RRSP deduction offsets your tax MPC tax of 11.2%, then dividend tax at your rate MPC tax of 11.2%
Tax on the yearly return None None Interest: 50.17%, with part refunded when the MPC pays dividends. Growth: none until you sell
Tax when you take it out All of it, as income at your rate None Dividend tax at your rate. A capital dividend is tax-free

Interest-type means the return is taxed in full every year, like interest from a GIC or a bond fund. Growth-type means the value rises and you sell nothing until the end.

Worked example: Dr. Rao's $100,000, made-up numbers

All numbers here are made up. Dr. Rao is an Ontario physician. Her MPC has $100,000 of profit left after living costs, before any MPC tax.

Step 1: how much can go in an RRSP or TFSA? Say she earned $200,000 last year and has no pension adjustment or unused room. 18% of $200,000 is $36,000, which is more than $35,390. So her RRSP room is $35,390.

Add the TFSA limit of $7,000 for 2026 (the CRA had not published the 2027 limit on 9 Oct 2026). The total is $42,390. The other $57,610 can only stay in the MPC.

Only the part that fits her room has this choice. Each result scales: $35,390 of room gives about 35% of each figure.

Assumptions (made up):

Her rate when she takes the money out:

Bracket in those years Ordinary income Non-eligible dividend
Top 53.53% 48.89%
Middle 44.97% 39.05%
Lower 29.65% 21.43%

Top means the highest federal and Ontario bands, with the Ontario surtax. Middle means the third federal band and the fourth Ontario band. Lower means about $80,000 of taxable income in those years, in the second band of each.

Ontario adds its surtax before it subtracts the dividend credit. The rates use the 2027 credit. They are rounded for display. The results use the unrounded rates, so your own sums can differ by a few dollars.

Interest-type return, top bracket, 10 years:

Line RRSP TFSA MPC
Pre-tax profit $100,000 $100,000 $100,000
MPC tax now nil (salary paid out) $11,200 $11,200
Personal tax now nil (RRSP deduction) $43,414 (48.89% of $88,800) nil
Money invested $100,000 $45,386 $88,800
Value after 10 years $162,889 $73,928 $128,828
Tax on taking out $87,194 (53.53%) nil $62,984 (48.89%)
Kept $75,695 $73,928 $65,844

The MPC's $128,828 is $113,579 of investments plus $15,249 of refundable tax. The investments grow by about 2.5% a year after the 50.17% tax. The $15,249 comes back when the MPC pays the dividend.

For the TFSA, the MPC first pays Dr. Rao an $88,800 dividend. She pays $43,414 of tax on it and puts the other $45,386 in the TFSA.

Salary can fund the TFSA too. At the top rate, $100,000 of salary leaves $46,470 to put in, and $75,695 after 10 years, the same as the RRSP. At the top rate with the 2027 Ontario credit, a dividend costs a little more in total than salary: about 54.6% (MPC tax plus dividend tax) against 53.53%.

Growth-type return, same inputs. The MPC holds $88,800 and sells nothing for 10 years.

  1. It grows to $144,646. The gain is $55,846.
  2. The taxable part is one-half of the gain, $27,923. Tax at 50.17% is $14,008. The refund when it pays dividends is $8,563.
  3. The MPC has $139,201 after tax and refund. $27,923 is the capital dividend, tax-free to her.
  4. The other $111,278 is a taxable dividend. Tax at 48.89% is $54,404.
  5. She keeps $27,923 + $56,874 = $84,797.

Results for all three brackets, and for 20 years:

Years and bracket RRSP MPC, interest-type MPC, growth-type
10, top $75,695 $65,844 $84,797
10, middle $89,639 $78,525 $95,751
10, lower $114,593 $101,222 $115,356
20, top $123,300 $92,011 $148,994
20, middle $146,012 $109,732 $163,552
20, lower $186,659 $141,448 $189,607

The TFSA gives $73,928 at 10 years and $120,421 at 20 years, whatever her bracket later. For interest-type income, the RRSP wins in every row. For growth you do not sell, the MPC wins in every row. A mix of the two lands in between: at the top bracket, 10 years, about $75,300.

Where the other $57,610 goes. It stays in the MPC. After 11.2% MPC tax, $51,158 a year is left to invest. Say she adds that every year at 5% interest and takes nothing out. After about 17 years the balance passes $1,000,000.

Its yearly interest then passes $50,000, so the next year her federal small business limit starts to fall (federal). That costs tax only on active income above the lower limit. With $300,000 of active income, for example, tax is lost only once AAII passes $90,000. Ontario keeps its limit (Ontario). This line assumes the same profit every year.

What changes the answer

1. The type of return. Interest is taxed in full every year, as in the interest column. A fund that pays out capital gains each year sits in between. Only one-half of each gain is taxed, and the other half can go out tax-free. But the MPC pays that tax every year, not at the end.

Dividends from Canadian shares held in the MPC pay a refundable tax of 38 1/3% inside the MPC (federal) (Income Tax Act, s. 186). The example does not model them. Ask your accountant before you rely on the growth column.

2. Your rate when you take the money out. A lower rate favours the RRSP over the MPC. In the 10-year growth case, the MPC's lead over the RRSP shrinks from $9,102 at the top bracket to $763 at the lower bracket. For interest, the RRSP's lead grows from $9,851 to $13,371.

3. Years invested. Twenty years widens every gap. At the top bracket, the RRSP leads interest-type by $31,289. The MPC leads the RRSP by $25,694 on growth.

4. Investment income past $50,000 (federal only). Each year, the federal small business limit falls by $5 for each $1 of last year's adjusted aggregate investment income (AAII) above $50,000 (Income Tax Act, s. 125). AAII counts interest, rent, dividends from shares the MPC holds, and the taxable part of gains.

The cut costs federal tax only on active income above the lower limit. Ontario keeps its full limit (Ontario). Investment income in your MPC works out the cost, and the eligible dividends that win part of it back.

5. When each choice is a poor one. The RRSP is poor for growth you plan to leave alone, or when a pension adjustment leaves you little room.

The MPC is poor for interest-type income, when AAII stays high enough for years to push the federal limit below your active income, or when you never plan to take the money out. The MPC gets the refund only when it pays you a taxable dividend, so money left inside for good never gets it back.

6. A change in the law. Ontario's non-eligible dividend credit drops by one percentage point on 1 January 2027. Each $1,000 of dividend paid in 2027 costs about $11.50 more Ontario tax than in 2026. See salary or dividends for how to mix pay.

Common mistakes

  1. Treating the whole surplus as RRSP money, or expecting room from dividends. Room caps it, and dividends create none.
  2. Adding Ontario's general rate to the cost of the federal cut. Ontario does not cut its limit, so only the federal gap applies: 15% instead of 9%.
  3. Comparing $100,000 in an RRSP with $100,000 in the MPC. The MPC has already paid 11.2%.
  4. Counting the whole gain as investment income. Only the taxable part counts.
  5. Missing the deadline. A 2026 RRSP contribution counts for 2026 if you make it by Monday 1 March 2027 (Income Tax Act, s. 146).

Next steps

  1. Find your RRSP deduction limit on your latest notice of assessment.
  2. Add up last year's MPC interest, rent, dividends from shares it holds, and realised gains. Count one-half of each gain. Compare with $50,000.
  3. Estimate your taxable income in retirement. Find your bracket in the rate table.
  4. Decide by Monday 1 March 2027 whether to contribute for 2026. That uses your 2026 room, not the 2027 room in the example.
  5. Ask your accountant to run your own numbers.

See Price, Start Free. The quote prices your corporate tax return (T2), so you see the cost before you start.

Sources

Price First

You Can See the Price and the Work Before You Pay a Dollar.

Exact price. No preliminary call. No surprise invoice.

See Price, Start Free
See Price, Start Free